ElementJester said:
Since when did HIC ever care about the players? She's using them as a means to an end, that's pretty much it.
Since when did HIC ever care about the players? She's using them as a means to an end, that's pretty much it.
Hence why I said it's unnatural. She doesn't belong there.
Tropylium said:
I'll agree on being annoyed by the Grimbark thing, though "Mary Sue" doesn't seem right. "Deus ex machina", maybe. We have no real explanation how she's being mindcontrolled-yet-herself, in a way that really looks more like brainwashing than anything HIC is supposed to have special powers for. She's just far too lucid to be a believable kind of creepy. (This works about right for Jane though, but the 'fridge' point holds for her I think.)
I'll agree on being annoyed by the Grimbark thing, though "Mary Sue" doesn't seem right. "Deus ex machina", maybe. We have no real explanation how she's being mindcontrolled-yet-herself, in a way that really looks more like brainwashing than anything HIC is supposed to have special powers for. She's just far too lucid to be a believable kind of creepy. (This works about right for Jane though, but the 'fridge' point holds for her I think.)
I'm not sure if "Deus ex machina" is exactly right either. Even though she attempts to assist the heroes into finishing the game, it's definitely not for their own benefit in the end. And yeah, I'm not exactly sure how Jade's mind control work considering the established rules of Taurus and Scorpio mind control. I'm thinking that the HIC somehow tapped into Jade's id somehow with her "sleep-talking", but she still seem relatively restrained for that. I could be wrong though.
That said I find Grimbark!Jade absurdly funny because she's essentially a try-hard teen who wants to be threatening and edgy. Like Karkat said she's threatening as mild flatulence.
Also yeah if Jade doesn't have a meltdown once she's back to normal, I'm calling bullshit.
Especially seeing that both Jade and Jadesprite had a double meltdown during their meeting with each other back in Act 5.2.
…And I have to wonder if any part of the hiatus involves Hussie trying to figure out how to tie together all the plot threads hanging here? He's neglected some of them long enough (when was the last time we saw Nannasprite actually doing anything? in passing around late Scratchstuck?), wouldn't be a surprize if new elements have forced rethinking where to take things.
I always thought it was a missed opportunity on Hussie's part in not getting a Nannasprite+John+Jade conversation on the Battleship(among other things on there) And I wouldn't be surprised if he taking hiatus to figure out where the story would go since it seems at times he doesn't know where he wants it to go.
(oh dear, this was near "what's wrong with Homestuck" territory.)